New York

22 Top-Rated Steakhouses in Mamaroneck, New York 2024

Jump to Spot

  • Image of Sedona Taphouse

    Sedona Taphouse

    4.4

    Sedona Taphouse, 640 E Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    At sedona taphouse, we serve fine craft beer and wine lovers alike in a warm, sophisticated environment. we work diligently to bring you the best in local and international craft beers, interesting wines and handcrafted martinis. our menu features hand-cut steaks, a variety of seafood offerings, gluten-free options and more. we have happy hour specials throughout the week and serve our full menu from open to close. we also have a patio with a firepit. discover a new favorite today at sedona taphouse!

    One review mentioned:

    Its definitely all about the beer here. there are about 30 taps and a large selection of bottles and cans available as well. the bacon wrapped jalapenos are excellent! new bartender needed help finding where my ordered tap was. cant blame him. i guess it takes some time to memorize them!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    12-10 PM

    Style: 
    New American restaurant

    (914) 341-1511
  • Image of SmokeHouse Tailgate Grill - Mamaroneck

    Smokehouse Tailgate Grill – Mamaroneck

    4.4

    SmokeHouse Tailgate Grill - Mamaroneck, 320 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Our menu is what we call tailgate bbq. we are known for our smoked swings, griddled burgers, & texas brisket. we have a great cocktail list, and carry 30+ craft beer drafts & cans!

    One review mentioned:

    Great tacos! kitchen a little on the slow side but worth the wait. good service. food

    Closed on: 
    Monday

    Timing: 
    11:30 AM-9 PM

    Style: 
    Barbecue restaurant

    (914) 341-1655
  • Image of Modern on the Rails

    Modern On The Rails

    4.6

    Modern on the Rails, 1 Station Plaza, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Historic building in metro north train station turned into a family owned and operated italian restaurant. outdoor patio and ample parking.
    private events, small or large, check out our ig

    One review mentioned:

    My son and daughter-in-law had their wedding at modern on the rails in january! the ambience was beautiful and romantic and so quaint… what a phenomenal event! the food was extremely well prepared and presented. the wait staff could not do enough to serve you, and were extremely attentive.. all of our relatives and friends in attendance raved about what an exceptional wedding venue it was, and a wonderful time was had by all. we are so grateful to the manager, lori for her hard work and dedication.. yes, it was our familys wedding, but it really was a wedding to remember.

    Closed on: 
    Monday

    Timing: 
    12-9:30 PM

    Style: 
    Italian restaurant

    (914) 777-9300
  • Harbour Fish Restaurant

    4.2

    Harbour Fish Restaurant, 576 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    The harbour fish restaurant, offers expertly prepared seafood in american, cajun, and latin inspired dishes. our chef, naldo morales, is a food connoisseur, having been the head chef and kitchen manager of a variety of prestigious restaurants ranging from bbq to fine dining. our dishes offer delectable combinations of fish, vegetables, and fried seafood that everyone will enjoy. you can also finish your meal with some of our house made desserts. our warm atmosphere and kind service will make you feel like family from the moment you walk in the door.

    in addition, we offer a huge range of catering services where our dishes can be served to parties, weddings, and other events. no event is too small!

    One review mentioned:

    Craving oysters and just picked this place on a whim to try when i googled fresh oysters. drove by it a million times and never noticed since it s not on the busy mamaroneck strip. it actually has additional parking in back. i would call this a hidden gem because you can easily overlook it due to the location and lack of curb presence. we had the prix fixe menu which was quite good value for three courses. oysters were great. we finished it too quickly before i remembered to take pictures. my snapper was fantastic. the branzino was very good but should have ordered the whole fish rather than fillet. the rum cake was delicious and reminded me of tres leche instead of the caribbean variety. cheesecake was excellent and better than the key lime. the latter a bit too sweet where as we preferred a sharper lime taste. they brought us the wrong one so we got to try both. there is a latin flavor to the dishes and not your typical southern deep fried seafood shack. it s clean and pleasant but a bit of thoughtful decorations might give it more atmosphere. the owners can either try more festive or more romantic. not sure which way i would go. the food and service are definitely excellent. will come back again.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    4-10 PM

    Style: 
    Seafood restaurant

    (914) 630-4790
  • Image of Le Provencal Bistro

    Le Provencal Bistro

    4.6

    Le Provencal Bistro, 436 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Le provencal is a mediterranean french restaurant that will warmly invite you in, with a flair that lives up to the highest standards. lunch is served monday through friday, brunch on saturday & sunday, and dinner seven nights a week.

    healthy alternatives and gluten-free choices are offered. the wine list is superbly chosen, including french wines and selected wines from around the world, all offering outstanding value.

    One review mentioned:

    I just came back from a delicious meal there. i had the monkfish special. it was amazing! escargot was the perfect appetizer. the dessert menu had incredible options. i had the bread pudding and i loved it. incredible service, great atmosphere. i cant wait to go back.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    12-2:45 PM, 5-9 PM

    Style: 
    Bistro

    (914) 777-2324
  • Image of La Herradura

    La Herradura

    4.0

    La Herradura, 406 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Authentic mexican restaurant on the block with a rustic ambiance for any gathering!

    One review mentioned:

    I have to say, ive worked at many fine dining mexican restaurants, ive eaten in many mexican restaurants, and i can say that this place is in my top 5 of best and must try! first, you are greeted with a smile and everyone says hello. once you sit you are able to really take in the amazing ambiance of the mexican culture, from aztec miniature statues to other beautiful art work. the service was amazing, very kind and friendly staff all around, we had our waiter and when he was busy, other people came to check on us or ask if we needed anything, that is a+ service. now, the food! it was tasty and amazing, the steak was cooked to perfection, even the chips which you can tell they make there, were amazing, but their salsa was to die for. their plantains were fried to perfection, i recommend having them add graded mexican cheese over it which really adds to the flavor. the fried ice cream is a stunner, they do it flambe style which added to the great evening, its prepared on a dish of rum, lit, and then drizzled with chocolate and raspberry. this place is a must try, they know how to run a business and it shows with every detail, every dish, every smile! via mexico!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11 AM-9 PM

    Style: 
    Mexican restaurant

    (914) 630-2375
  • Image of Red Plum

    Red Plum

    4.3

    Red Plum, 251 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Modern pan-asian fare plus yakitori, sushi & sashimi in stylish, low-lit quarters with a marble bar.

    One review mentioned:

    Visited this restaurant for lunch on a weekday, it was nice and empty so service was pretty fast. drinks were strong and so good. i had a lychee cocktail. sesame chicken was really delicious and so was the shrimp fried rice. the mushroom soup was also very good. atmosphere was very nice, could be a nice place for date night. do recommend and will return.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11:30 AM-9 PM

    Style: 
    Pan-Asian restaurant

    (914) 777-8696
  • Image of Enzo's Restaurant

    Enzo’S Restaurant

    4.4

    Enzo's Restaurant, 451 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Trained in the old country and experienced from years of restaurant ownership in new york, enzo’s chef expertly prepares vitello (veal), pollo (chicken), bistecca (steak) and pesce (fish) entrees with panache. his stylish pasta creations combine tasty sauces and locally grown ingredients.

    owner luciano savone recognizes the importance of maintaining the legacy of fine italian cuisine. when you visit his ristorante, you feel transported to another land where the atmosphere is warm and relaxed, where staff members who go way back are like family and part of the legend.

    to be italian is to appreciate the contribution of sophisticated wine and spirits to elegant dining.

    One review mentioned:

    My family and i travel the world and explore many dishes. enzo s brought us back to italy. even my 10 year old noticed the superb taste. this place is the real deal. the real italian taste. even in italy you wait for greatness. westchester county s italian masterpiece.

    Closed on: 
    Tuesday

    Timing: 
    12-10 PM

    Style: 
    Italian restaurant

    (914) 698-2911
  • Image of 25 North

    25 North

    4.7

    25 North, 974 E Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Comfortable indoor & outdoor tented dining, take-out plus full service on & off premise catering….

    One review mentioned:

    Spectacular food. ive had only delicious things here. highly recommend the carbonara and the godfather. john is a great waiter and the atmosphere is lovely, although it can get very busy and loud. its a testament to their popularity. you cant go wrong here. highly recommend the canoli, its homemade and fresh. honestly, its pretty good value for the caliber of food.

    Closed on: 
    Monday

    Timing: 
    5-9:30 PM

    Style: 
    Italian restaurant

    (914) 698-2597
  • Image of DonJito

    Donjito

    4.5

    DonJito, 122 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Donjito, the latest restaurant venture from jito hospitality group, celebrates the traditions of spain, mexico, and south america with wonderfully influenced nuevo latino offerings. using produce and meats from regional farms and sustainable seafood, donjito’s sole mission is to provide the customer with a wonderful dining experience.
    located in the heart of the sound shore towns, we offer healthy, and delicious lunches and dinners along with a wonderful cocktail menu sangrias, and wines designed to enhance your meal.

    One review mentioned:

    This place has become the spot for birthday dinners for about a year. food is amazing! everything that we have tried has been delicious, food and drinks. service is great as well. can t forget about presentation and decor a1! i also love how they have ambience for everyone for example- live music, vallenato night, fun brunch, violinist and more. i definitely recommend this place, you will not be disappointed!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11:30 AM-11 PM

    Style: 
    Nuevo Latino restaurant

    (914) 902-5486
  • Image of Mamaroneck Diner & Pizza Restaurant

    Mamaroneck Diner & Pizza Restaurant

    4.2

    Mamaroneck Diner & Pizza Restaurant, 405 E Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Basic round-the-clock diner with a huge menu including pizzas & all-day breakfast.

    One review mentioned:

    Weve been twice. the first time was in the evening with a group of eight. we were seated quickly and everyone enjoyed their food. they have an extensive childrens menu which helped with the five kids we had with us. the second time we went was for a late breakfast. i enjoyed the sante fe skillet.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    6 AM-10:30 PM

    Style: 
    Diner

    (914) 698-3564
  • Image of Rani Mahal Fine Indian Cuisine

    Rani Mahal Fine Indian Cuisine

    4.6

    Rani Mahal Fine Indian Cuisine, 320-322 Phillips Park Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    When you want indian food in mamaroneck, ny, come to rani mahal fine indian cuisine. we offer a wide array of traditional cuisine such as chicken tikka masala, tandoori fish, sag paneer, lamb rogan josh, and much more. our food is prepared daily with the freshest ingredients and served by our friendly staff. we want to exceed your expectations when it comes to quality food and drinks. order your favorite indian dishes at rani mahal fine indian cuisine!

    One review mentioned:

    The food was delicious – best nan bread i ve ever tasted ! the owner was really nice and friendly. highly recommended.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11:30 AM-2:30 PM, 5-9 PM

    Style: 
    Indian restaurant

    (914) 835-9066
  • Image of The Roaster Cafe & Bistro

    The Roaster Cafe & Bistro

    4.3

    The Roaster Cafe & Bistro, 419 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Discover perfection at the roaster cafe & bistro on mamaroneck avenue in mamaroneck, ny! in the heart of 10543, our cafe blends exquisite coffee with culinary expertise. immerse yourself in a warm atmosphere, enjoying freshly roasted coffee and gourmet bistro delights.

    from expertly crafted espressos to diverse menu options, our commitment to quality shines. the roaster is your haven for coffee enthusiasts and food connoisseurs. whether you’re seeking a cozy spot for a morning pick-me-up, a casual lunch with friends, or an intimate dinner, our cafe and bistro provide the perfect backdrop
    join us at 419 mamaroneck avenue for an unforgettable experience in coffee culture and culinary excellence. best turkish cafe & bistro in westchester.

    One review mentioned:

    My first time being here as a turkish and i like the authentic athmosphere as well as the food. i had sunnyside eggs with beef gyro, appetizer platter(babaganoush, shakshuka, dill weed dip, black beans and hummus) it was very good! and then one piece of turkish pistachio baklava and belgian waffle ( they have gluten free option as well). also i met with the owner and i thank him for his hospitality. he was so nice and attentive. i would defititely recommend this place and will definitely come back again! 10/10!!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    7 AM-9 PM

    Style: 
    Restaurant

    (914) 630-2954
  • Image of Nonna Carola Ristorante and Bar

    Nonna Carola Ristorante And Bar

    4.6

    Nonna Carola Ristorante and Bar, 211 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    We are a brand new high end casual italian restaurant focusing on traditional family recipes with a modern twist.

    One review mentioned:

    Had a fabulous party with 12 guests. i used the price fix menu which was so much food and lots of choices for the main course. the food was 10/10 as was our server oliver. they went above and beyond to make sure we had an amazing night. our fantastic waiter oliver even went out of his way to take lots of great group photos for us. i will definitely be doing more events at nonna, 5 stars aren t enough!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    12-10 PM

    Style: 
    Italian restaurant

    (914) 899-3130
  • Image of Frankie & Fanucci's

    Frankie & Fanucci’S

    4.2

    Frankie & Fanucci's, 301 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Frankie & fanucci’s cranks out authentic, thin-crust pizza out of old school, wood-burning ovens running at 900+ degrees.
    voted best of westchester for 6 years!
    everything is made from scratch in our kitchens daily, using the freshest ingredients.

    One review mentioned:

    The food is excellent every time we go there and the customer service is very good. it was nicely decorated for christmas, making the atmosphere more welcoming.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    12-9 PM

    Style: 
    Restaurant

    (914) 630-4360
  • Image of Hash O Nash

    Hash O Nash

    4.3

    Hash O Nash, 441 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Welcome to hash o nash middle eastern country kitchen, located at 441 mamaroneck avenue. indulge in a culinary journey with the finest middle eastern cuisine in our cozy and inviting atmosphere. our menu boasts a diverse range of delectable dishes, from flavorful falafels and creamy hummus to succulent chicken kabob, shawarma, and gyros. savor the freshness of our middle eastern salads and experience the rich flavors of mediterranean cuisine.

    a family-oriented atmosphere where you can enjoy exceptional food in the company of your loved ones. join us for a unique dining experience and immerse yourself in the warmth of our hospitality. make your weekends extra special on friday and saturday.

    One review mentioned:

    Everything is freshly made and deliciously seasoned. the restaurant has a beautiful authentic decor. i ordered the 1/2 lamb 1/2 chicken shwarma that comes with salad and homemade delicious dressing and rice pilaf. my friend ordered the salmon kabob. both were generous portions. the lemonade is so refreshing, you can taste the fresh spear mint and it s like a slushie. also tried the spicy hummus and they have a great variety to choose from. there is plenty of parking depending when you go. mamaroneck avenue is a street full of restaurants so sometimes you have to wait until someone pulls out. i also ordered from them delivery and it s just as good. i come all the way from ct to get this authentic mediterranean experience. great selection for vegetarians, pescatarians and meat eaters alike. for example, they have chicken kabob, shrimp kabob, salmon kabob, and tons of veggie options. vegetarian options: lentils, eggplant. salads parking: paid parking meters in street. free sundays.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11 AM-9 PM

    Style: 
    Middle Eastern restaurant

    (914) 630-7310
  • Image of Best Chinese Restaurant

    Best Chinese Restaurant

    4.3

    Best Chinese Restaurant, 351 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Homey chinese spot offering a sizable menu of fried rice, lo mein & other basics in informal digs.

    One review mentioned:

    Best is my favorite chinese take out! the food is good and usually they are ready in 15 minutes. people working there are so friendly and attentive to your order! the prices are great too! they do have some tables there but i would recommend take out instead.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11 AM-10 PM

    Style: 
    Chinese restaurant

    (914) 698-1333
  • Image of Nautilus Diner

    Nautilus Diner

    4.3

    Nautilus Diner, 1240 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Neighborhood diner open 24 hours offering basic grub, from all-day breakfast to burgers & salads.

    One review mentioned:

    My friends brought me here after my birthday party to top off the celebration with this pumkin spice cheesecake… the atmosphere, food, and service at the nautilus is always top tier… but the way i think about this cheesecake all year long … 10 out of 10 would highly recommend!! parking: the lot at times is packed, but be patient the customers are considerate and pull out in a timely manner, just stay alert.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    7 AM-11 PM

    Style: 
    Diner

    (914) 833-1320
  • Image of Zenzo Sushi

    Zenzo Sushi

    4.3

    Zenzo Sushi, 328 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    My linda valentine

    One review mentioned:

    We stopped randomly at zenzo. we went to another place first, but it smelled weird. in contrast zenzo was cozy and the service was amazing. waitress was very cool. most importantly the food was delicious . will definitely come back again. we ordered spicy salmon roll, untouchable roll, and salmon avocado, salmon mango roll. it was so good that we will came back here again.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11:30 AM-9:30 PM

    Style: 
    Japanese restaurant

    (914) 381-0888
  • Image of Pizza Gourmet Restaurant

    Pizza Gourmet Restaurant

    4.6

    Pizza Gourmet Restaurant, 599 E Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Pizza gourmet restaurant has been serving westchester county and the surrounding communities since 1998 with southern italian pizza and cuisine.

    One review mentioned:

    Came in late last night right as they were closing, and the young gentleman behind the counter was very helpful. although he was working alone, he was willing to help us and stood open late to make us a pizza gourmet. i highly recommend as it was delicious and one of the best pies i have had in a long time with lots of seasoning. we will definitely come back!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11 AM-9 PM

    Style: 
    Pizza restaurant

    (914) 777-1056
  • Image of Spicy Shallot 2 Thai Restaurant

    Spicy Shallot 2 Thai Restaurant

    4.2

    Spicy Shallot 2 Thai Restaurant, 1208 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Best authentic thai cuisine

    One review mentioned:

    This is my favorite go-to restaurant for lunch and dinner. the staff is always prompt and friendly and the food is always high quality and consistent. the restaurant is clean and pleasant. i only wish there are more restaurants like this one.

    Closed on: 
    Monday

    Timing: 
    11:30 AM-3 PM, 5-9:30 PM

    Style: 
    Thai restaurant

    (914) 833-1200
  • Image of Ginban Asian Bistro

    Ginban Asian Bistro

    4.4

    Ginban Asian Bistro, 421 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

    Ginban asian bistro located in the heart of mamaroneck, offers an extensive menu from thai, chinese and japanese cuisine.
    the complexity associated with creating the perfect sushi starts with the freshest seafood, fresh wasabi and the ideal sushi rice. these elements are what ginban believes in and this is what captures the true essence of our food. come visit ginban sushi bar and watch its amazing chefs create cutting edge sushi, or come experience fine asian cuisine in our dining area.

    One review mentioned:

    You will always get a solid meal at ginban. consistently fresh and tasty sushi. hot dishes are also flavorful. the menu has a nice balance of offering, not overwhelming in options but ample choices for everyone to find a favorite. all the wait staff is excellent and of particular note thomas is personable, kind and helpful. he knows our family by name and makes us feel more than welcome every time we come which is several times a month.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11:30 AM-3:30 PM, 4:30-9:30 PM

    Style: 
    Japanese restaurant

    (914) 777-8889
juanitasdiner
Juanita MariaWriter

I believe food is more than just something to eat - it's an art form that brings people together.

Juanitasdiner.com

All Posts
Don't miss out! Share this with your friends.

You Might Also Like: