Ohio

21 Top-Rated Steakhouses in Westerville, Ohio 2024

Jump to Spot

  • Image of Asterisk Supper Club

    Asterisk Supper Club

    4.6

    Asterisk Supper Club, 14 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081

    Sophisticated locale for afternoon tea, craft cocktails & upmarket american cuisine.

    One review mentioned:

    My husband accompanied me on a weekend get away for work and through word of mouth i was told about this place. i am a tea lover and that is why we made this stop. what we got was so much more! we ended up getting recommendations from micah (an amazing staff member) on some tasty dishes and they by far exceeded our expectations. everything from the vibe, food, staff, recommendations, everything was amazing! i cant say how great the staff is enough! micah and derek were amazing and we cant wait to go back. so glad we stopped in. we also had seen someone having a smoked old fashion and that was fun to watch them make and was amazing. thank you micah and derek for making our visit incredible. we will be back.

    Closed on:  Monday

    Timing:  12-9 PM

    Style:  Restaurant

    (614) 776-4633
  • Image of The Two-One Restaurant

    The Two-One Restaurant, Bar & Patio

    4.2

    The Two-One Restaurant, Bar & Patio, 409 Altair Pkwy, Westerville, OH 43082

    Offers a sophisticated, but relaxed dining and entertainment experience. join us on friday and saturday nights and listen to columbus best musicians play live. ideally located in the renaissance columbus westerville hotel serving breakfast monday through friday from 6:30am-11am, 7am-12 saturday and 7a-2p on sunday, dinner served daily from 4pm-10pm while the two-one bar is open sunday through thursday from 4pm-11pm and friday/saturday 4p-12a.

    One review mentioned:

    I didn t bring my phone to dinner so unfortunately was unable to take photos, but the food is delicious! very fresh, clearly made in house from scratch, and priced reasonably with generous portions. the menu selection was impressive and the happy hour specials can t be beat. environment/ambiance is also very modern and romantic. i was extremely impressed with two-one and it could stand alone with any non-hotel restaurant in the area. whether you are staying at the renaissance or not, i would highly recommend it!

    Closed on:  Open All Days

    Timing:  4-10 PM

    Style:  American restaurant

    (614) 882-6800
  • Image of Cardone's Restaurant & Bar

    Cardone’S Restaurant & Bar

    4.6

    Cardone's Restaurant & Bar, 377 W Main St, Westerville, OH 43081

    Casual fine dining italian restaurant in westerville with old world atmosphere, authentic dishes & exceptional wines. voted best italian in columbus, oh area.

    One review mentioned:

    Reservations will assure you a visit, you dont want to miss this one. from the full staff getting at the door, to the constant attention and variety menu. wow. appetizers were fantastic. entrees were fantastic. bread was really really good. great ambiance. if i had a complaint it would be the close quarters to others, which in this restaurant, was good company. cannot wait to eat here again. both of us really enjoyed this meal.

    Closed on:  Monday, Sunday

    Timing:  4-9 PM

    Style:  Italian restaurant

    (614) 392-2267
  • Image of Westerville Grill

    Westerville Grill

    4.4

    Westerville Grill, 59 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081

    Relaxed diner offering hearty servings of breakfast-to-dinner comfort food & pie in several flavors.

    One review mentioned:

    I m a huge fan of local diners and westerville grill did not disappoint. located in downtown westerville, it s amongst the happenings especially on the weekend. i enjoyed a classic steak and eggs. the steak was cooked to medium rare as i requested. the eggs were paired with crispy toast and a side of bacon (the bacon was not as crispy as i prefer but was well salted). also can t forget about the home fries. overall meal was very satisfying. there were a lot of other items on the menu i d like to try out next time i come here. and perhaps next time i will sit inside the diner. it s nice that they have a patio for the summer. lastly i d like to say the staff were very friendly and accommodating.

    Closed on:  Monday

    Timing:  8 AM-3 PM

    Style:  Restaurant

    (614) 794-7200
  • Image of Giammarco's Italian Restaurant

    Giammarco’S Italian Restaurant

    4.5

    Giammarco's Italian Restaurant, 6030 Chandler Ct, Westerville, OH 43082

    Giammarco’s italian restaurant has been offering authentic italian cuisine like our award winning pizza and stromboli in westerville ohio since 1999. we are a family owned & operated italian restaurant that uses our age-old family recipes with only the finest and freshest ingredients available. we have catering options for all types of special occasions. our restaurant offers off site catering as well as a private dining room for group functions. our staff will accommodate all of your needs and special requests. let us do all the work and let you enjoy a glass of your favorite wine or beer from our large selection. we will make your dining experience so memorable that you will keep coming back again and again.

    One review mentioned:

    We really like giamarcos but hadnt been since bc (before covid). its still just as good as we remember. pizza pillows are quite good. pro tip: happy hour pricing for drinks and appetizers is m-f 4-6. main courses were very good. shared a small gelato for the perfect ending. (oddly not listed on the dessert menu.) only disappointment was the beer menu was lacking in stouts and porters. but to be fair, thats true for most italian restaurants.

    Closed on:  Open All Days

    Timing:  11 AM-10 PM

    Style:  Italian restaurant

    (614) 895-8890
  • Image of Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

    Rusty Bucket Restaurant And Tavern

    4.4

    Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern, 400 Polaris Pkwy, Westerville, OH 43082

    Rusty bucket is a casual american restaurant and tavern, a gathering place where people come to share laughter, smiles, and great conversation over food that makes everyone happy. satisfying and familiar, the menu is classic american fare, thoughtfully prepared from scratch by each location’s executive chef. cocktails are considered a craft, made-to-order by highly-skilled bartenders. from barrel to glass, no short cuts are taken with the carefully selected beer list. the perfect draft is guaranteed. join us for lunch, grab a drink after work, bring the kids for dinner – we’ve got a seat for you!

    One review mentioned:

    Wonderful for a nice sit down or quick bite. great happy hour prices – and our little one was good for 98% of the visit! ashlie was a great server with awesome service. will be back again.

    Closed on:  Sunday

    Timing:  11 AM-10 PM

    Style:  American restaurant

    (614) 890-3663
  • Image of NAPA Kitchen + Bar Westerville

    Napa Kitchen + Bar Westerville

    4.3

    NAPA Kitchen + Bar Westerville, 925 N State St, Westerville, OH 43082

    Welcome to napa kitchen + bar! our modern restaurant in westerville, oh, celebrates creative food with memorable wines, providing an unforgettable experience. you’ll enjoy a fresh, innovative menu inspired by mediterranean flavors served in a casual napa style. everything we offer is perfect for sharing and pairing! choose from oven-fired pizzas, creative sandwiches, cheese boards with cured meats, and more. we also offer an extensive drink menu, with several wines by the glass and refreshing cocktails. so whether you are looking for the perfect date night location, a tasty weekend brunch, refreshing small plates, or a trip around the wine world, this is the place for you. make every visit a new adventure. visit napa kitchen + bar today.

    One review mentioned:

    Went here for our valentines date night (had reservations). the restaurant has a very nice decor and atmosphere. our server (taylor) was super friendly and attentive and had good recommendations. i had the beef short ribs with risotto and my wife had the grilled shrimp with risotto. both were delicious. and the bread pudding for dessert was awesome. definitely will add this restaurant to our local list.

    Closed on:  Open All Days

    Timing:  11 AM-9 PM

    Style:  Restaurant

    (614) 523-4330
  • Image of Jimmy V's Grill & Pub

    Jimmy V’S Grill & Pub

    4.2

    Jimmy V's Grill & Pub, 1 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081

    Outpost of a local bar & grill chain, serving american pub grub & drinks in a sports-bar setting.

    One review mentioned:

    Everything we had was delicious. only complaint is my husband asked for no tomato and his gyro had tomato on it. if youre wanting good greek food, you will love this place. we did.

    Closed on:  Open All Days

    Timing:  11 AM-2:30 AM

    Style:  Bar & grill

    (614) 865-9090
  • Image of Thai Grille

    Thai Grille

    4.5

    Thai Grille, 15 E College Ave, Westerville, OH 43081

    Casual thai mainstay serving a seasonal, area-sourced menu of traditional dishes in quaint quarters.

    One review mentioned:

    While passing through ohio, we stumbled upon a charming thai restaurant in the downtown area. the food, including pad thai, fried rice, chicken cashew nut, satay chicken, and tofu, was excellent. despite the modest appearance of the restaurant, the quality of the food was outstanding. the chef personally served us and was truly wonderful. the restroom facilities were not impressive, but this did not detract from the overall experience. it seemed that some other customers were regulars who knew the staff and chef well, suggesting that it may be a longstanding family-owned business. if you are in the mood for delicious thai cuisine, i highly recommend paying this restaurant a visit.

    Closed on:  Monday

    Timing:  11 AM-9 PM

    Style:  Thai restaurant

    (614) 865-4515
  • Image of Koble Grill

    Koble Grill

    4.5

    Koble Grill, 7 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081

    Relaxed standby offering greek & italian eats, such as gyros & pasta, plus a bar area & happy hours.

    One review mentioned:

    Really enjoyed my first visit here. had the grouper with shrimp and it was cooked very well. the sauce and rice really made it a great meal. would come back again.

    Closed on:  Open All Days

    Timing:  11 AM-10 PM

    Style:  Greek restaurant

    (614) 882-6366
  • Image of Wendell's Pub

    Wendell’S Pub

    4.1

    Wendell's Pub, 925 N State St, Westerville, OH 43082

    Housemade soups, salads, seafood, pasta dishes & bar bites in a charming spot with outdoor seats.

    One review mentioned:

    Our waitress, kim, was friendly and attentive. the fish and chips was well cooked, delicious and huge. will definitely go again to try more items.

    Closed on:  Monday

    Timing:  12-10 PM

    Style:  American restaurant

    (614) 818-0400
  • Image of The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Westerville

    The Old Bag Of Nails Pub – Westerville

    4.3

    The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Westerville, 24 N State St 26 # 26, Westerville, OH 43081

    Branch of a local bar chain serving american comfort food & signature battered fish ‘n’ chips.

    One review mentioned:

    The mussels and shrimp are amazing. a repeat dish for me at this restaurant. i dont eat chocolate, but it had a nice presentation, and it was mentioned it was very good. i like a good bloody mary and theirs were on point. very nice atmosphere. went during the week, not crowded. the service was amazing. didnt need to ask for anything. totally recommend this place for a nice, casual dining experience.

    Closed on:  Open All Days

    Timing:  11 AM-9 PM

    Style:  Pub

    (614) 794-6900
  • Image of El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant

    El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant

    4.3

    El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant, 420 Polaris Pkwy, Westerville, OH 43082

    Mexican food from the range to you at el vaquero! the freshest meats paired with unique spices and a bouquet of colorful vegetables make each dish a truly authentic mexican dining experience. our recipes celebrate the proud traditions of making real food for real people, and each meal at el vaquero is made the way it was centuries ago on the range! our menu includes all of your tantalizing favorites like fajitas, enchiladas, burritos, rellenos, quesadillas, tacos, steak, and more! our regulars also say we have the best margaritas in town. but don’t take their word for it, why not come by and try them for yourself? we didn’t forget about those of you with more discerning palates: we have a wide variety of vegetarian meals available too.

    One review mentioned:

    Went here on a saturday evening and got seated right away. i got a beer and burrito deluxe plate and it was delicious. my server was really good and kind. my food came out really fast after i ordered it. im really impressed with this place and will be coming back.

    Closed on:  Open All Days

    Timing:  11 AM-10 PM

    Style:  Mexican restaurant

    (614) 392-2045
  • Image of The Pancake House Westerville Family Diner.

    The Pancake House Westerville Family Diner.

    4.5

    The Pancake House Westerville Family Diner., 129 W Schrock Rd, Westerville, OH 43081

    Note: phone orders are pre-paid only (same as online orders). rationale: losses due to no shows or orders picks up without paying. thank you for your understanding.

    given current labor market challenges, you are encouraged to use our online ordering instead of phone orders. our entire menu is available on our user friendly online ordering system. your submitted order will print directly to our kitchen.

    One review mentioned:

    Wow, i am truly happy with this visit. working out of town, and just craved a local diner breakfast. i was not disappointed. the chorizo skillet was fantastic. order a burrito sized tortilla to help sop and wrap! ana provided wonderful service. this is a spot to add as a must stop, and a revisit. parking is very limited at the resturant, but a shopping center is next door, with plenty of spots. helps to walk off the amazing calories consumed.

    Closed on:  Sunday

    Timing:  6:30 AM-2:30 PM

    Style:  American restaurant

    (614) 898-6500
  • Image of Lucky House Chinese Restaurant

    Lucky House Chinese Restaurant

    4.5

    Lucky House Chinese Restaurant, 56 E Schrock Rd, Westerville, OH 43081

    We will no longer be serving our sunday buffet.

    One review mentioned:

    Best and kindest service around. my husband and i came for the $45 special for two! soup! appetizer! entree! dessert! the portions are huge and the food is so comforting and delicious. we all need to eat in chinese more often. we got the egg drop soup and wonton to start. then 4 (yes 4) full size, hot and crispy egg rolls for our appetizer. chicken pad thai and triple delicacy for entrees were amazing and fresh. then 2 pices of triple chocolate cake for dessert. we were in heaven! thanks so much to our wonderful server and the older gentleman who kept refilling our drinks. we will be back! vegetarian options: kitchen is flexible and can make what you need. dietary restrictions: kitchen was flexible with my onion/garlic sensitivity.

    Closed on:  Open All Days

    Timing:  11 AM-8 PM

    Style:  Chinese restaurant

    (614) 898-9860
  • Image of Northstar Cafe in Uptown Westerville

    Northstar Cafe In Uptown Westerville

    4.5

    Northstar Cafe in Uptown Westerville, 109 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081

    Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner daily. focused on delicious, healthful food, welcoming spaces and sharing the love!

    One review mentioned:

    I still cant stop talking about how delicious it was *deep breath* ok, the food here is amazing. to die for. delicious. (i cant think of any more synonyms for it tastes good). they have a large variety of options but i definitely recommend theyre fish sandwiches !! the staff is very friendly and treated us very very well . parking is a little tough but overall i rate it a: ! we love u northstar vegetarian options: there are vegetarian options!! parking: parking can be tough (but you are tougher ), so be prepared! kid-friendliness: its very kid friendly!

    Closed on:  Open All Days

    Timing:  9 AM-10 PM

    Style:  American restaurant

    (614) 394-8992
  • Image of Las Margaritas - Westerville

    Las Margaritas – Westerville

    4.4

    Las Margaritas - Westerville, 706 N State St, Westerville, OH 43082

    Festive local chain serving a menu of mexican favorites, plus margaritas & imported beers.

    One review mentioned:

    So we bounce in here for a late afternoon lunch very early dinner, and this place is astounding. the host who i suspect is the owner of the place is awesome very funny and very chris matic . we sat at the bar, had a couple drinks and had our meal, and it was great . what are the striking things about? this place is almost seems like a tiki hut with the way they have the set up in the atmosphere. frankly, i can t see how this place could have anything less than five stars across-the-board it was that awesome and i would recommend it to anybody . in fact, i think i found my newest, most favorite mexican restaurant in the columbus, ohio/luis center/westerville area .

    Closed on:  Open All Days

    Timing:  11 AM-9:30 PM

    Style:  Mexican restaurant

    (614) 568-0600
  • Image of Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House

    Pasquale’S Pizza & Pasta House

    4.6

    Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House, 558 W Schrock Rd, Westerville, OH 43081

    Family owned business

    One review mentioned:

    If you live close to this place and havent tried it, shame on you!! we were looking for pizza and pasta for lunch from somewhere we had never been before. that is always a little scary!! we fortunately picked pasquales. we ordered the garlic knots. they are huge, crispy where they need to be and chewy not doughy. and so cheap!! we decided to try the meat lovers pizza and the penne and meatball too. neither dish disappointed. the crust is so thin and crispy but not burnt at all and the amount of toppings was very generous. we have a lot of leftovers to take home. we both decided we would make the 45 min drive to eat here again and again. the server makayla (sp?) was very friendly and the speed of service was great!! then there is the dessert case. we brought home a cannoli, a cream puff , a cinnamon roll and the peanut butter cookie sandwich with chocolate. so excited to try them too!

    Closed on:  Monday, Sunday

    Timing:  11 AM-8 PM

    Style:  Pizza restaurant

    (614) 882-6200
  • Image of City Barbeque

    City Barbeque

    4.3

    City Barbeque, 600 S State St, Westerville, OH 43081

    Fast-casual barbeque restaurant serving authentic comfort food. serves award-winning bbq, huge sandwiches, homemade sides, fresh salads, and incredible desserts. all meats–beef brisket, pulled pork, st. louis-cut ribs, amish chickens, turkey breast, and special-recipe sausage–are smoked on site, and all sides and desserts are made fresh daily in the restaurant. caters thousands of events every year, of all sizes and styles: everything from formal weddings and backyard graduation parties to company picnics and family reunions. great for lunch, dinner, dine-in, or carryout. supports teammates and communities alike; prioritizes giving back to local charities and non-profits.

    One review mentioned:

    Brought my whole family here thought to try something new. was greeted on entry by the manager. he was very friendly and super helpful. restaurant was clean and had a good atmosphere. the brisket sandwich was great. my kids got the ribs and those were awesome as well. would definitely recommend.

    Closed on:  Open All Days

    Timing:  11 AM-9 PM

    Style:  Barbecue restaurant

    (614) 823-8890
  • Image of Sapporo Sushi Factory

    Sapporo Sushi Factory

    4.4

    Sapporo Sushi Factory, 732 N State St, Westerville, OH 43082

    Strip-mall location serving maki & nigiri sushi as well as japanese favorites in a casual setting.

    One review mentioned:

    This place is so cute. presentation is immaculate and the food is delicious! we will be back! i had the edemamme dinner set c which was amazing. vegetarian options: there is so much on the menu for vegetarians. dietary restrictions: i have a garlic / onion sensitivity they were able to accommodate. parking: large parking lot. kid-friendliness: casual eating, kids welcome. wheelchair accessibility: large space accommodation for wheelchairs.

    Closed on:  Monday

    Timing:  4-8:45 PM

    Style:  Sushi restaurant

    (614) 895-7575
  • Image of 101 Beer Kitchen

    101 Beer Kitchen

    4.5

    101 Beer Kitchen, 817 Polaris Pkwy, Westerville, OH 43082

    Every neighborhood has that one gathering spot that feels welcoming and familiar when you’re longing for comfort, and fresh and exciting when you’re craving something new. it is the aspiration of every 101 beer kitchen to be that place.

    food & beer and, more precisely, the pairing of the two is at the core of what 101 beer kitchen is all about. whether you start with our seasonal, chef-driven menu or with your favorite brew, we’ll help you find its perfect complement.

    One review mentioned:

    Everything is amazing every time. great service, scratch kitchen with amazing menu that changes seasonally, and great atmosphere for conversations in groups or pairs. this time we went there for appetizers and drinks: we had the spinach and artichoke flatbread, loaded housemade tater tots, tangerine wheat beer and can t remember the name of a really good stout beer.

    Closed on:  Sunday

    Timing:  11:30 AM-9 PM

    Style:  Gastropub

    (614) 776-4775
juanitasdiner
Juanita MariaWriter

I believe food is more than just something to eat - it's an art form that brings people together.

Juanitasdiner.com

All Posts
Don't miss out! Share this with your friends.

Restaurant Styles

You Might Also Like: