8 Top-Rated Steakhouses in Amherst, New York 2024

Terrific dinner, and great service from our servers. it was a wonderful time out for valentine s day. the sides are definitely shareable, and the food was absolutely delicious. it felt like anytime we took a sip of water, the servers would be at our side refilling our cups, they were so attentive. they bring over pretzel bread, and another type as well. we both got cesar salads to start, i got a 7 oz filet mignon, and he got the 16oz 60 day dry aged new york strip. i also got a jumbo size king crab leg, while my husband got shrimp. with any order of steak you can get one of their house made sauces to dip it in, (they have 6 different kinds)no extra charge. i got the red wine demi glaze, and the bearnaise as well which tasted great with my steak. i liked the red wine demi a little more tho . for sides we got the french fries that come with an herb aioli and ketchup, as well as the creamed kale which wasn t bad, if you like kale. to finish off, we got the warm chocolate bomb cake, it was very good but so rich. it came with vanilla ice cream which helped. i can say we left stuffed but very happy, and satisfied. we will be back

Had a server named rachelle and she was absolutely incredible. made the whole experience feel like as if we knew her personally. she was not afraid to actually show her personality and sense of humor unlike most waitresses i ve had who seem almost robotic. the food was amazing ( highly recommend the blooming onion ) and it was valentine s day so the atmosphere was very romantic.

What can you say ? its jims steak out, a buffalo staple. the food is ridiculously good. could use a little cleaning, and its kind of expensive, but man…its worth it.

Had christmas dinner here with my mom and was not disappointed at all. the food was great and so were the drinks. had left over for the next day because their servings are so generous. love this place!

My then boyfriend surprised me for our valentines day 2023 with going to jazzboline! it was a great experience. loved the food and had a great time. it was nice seeing the kitchen as your food was being made. the duck wings were amazing, creme brulee dessert, and drinks, too–highly recommended! entrees were also delicious. we will definitely be going back!!

Excellent food and staff! i showed the bartender a drink from another spot from another state and she attempted and almost perfected it lol. the food was delicious, the atmosphere was warm and the set up was great. the prices were fair and the food did not take long to get to the table. highly recommend if you re in the amherst area.

Its a nice family restaurant! we went on a thursday night and it was a little busy but nothing crazy. we did wait a while for our order but it was for a a large group of people. my minor complaints are the waitress never came back to our table to check on us after dropping our food off (everyone has always come back at least once). my husband even had to chase her down for the check. and my friend didnt finish his burger bc it was ordered well-done but it was more like medium well. prices are fair for down home cooking though! great selection of cocktails.

In my opinion carrabba s is underrated. the food is always delicious no matter what you order. cocktails are on a sweeter side but still worth the reasonable price. we always get great service at this location and i highly recommend this place for any occasion.