New York

18 Top-Rated Steakhouses in Centereach, New York 2024

Jump to Spot

  • Image of Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Restaurant

    Michael Anthony’S Pizzeria & Restaurant

    4.2

    Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Restaurant, 2425 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Michael anthony’s is known for great pizza and also for having many great gluten-free options among are appetizers, pasta dishes, entrees and yes we have dessert. dine-in for additional options on the menu that you can only receive when you dine in our dining room.

    One review mentioned:

    Was there last night! wonderful experience! met mike, the owner and gina was our waitress. such nice people! the food and service was excellent! thank you both for making our dinner experience wonderful! we will be back!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11 AM-9 PM

    Style: 
    Pizza restaurant

    (631) 285-7722
  • Image of White Castle

    White Castle

    4.0

    White Castle, 2201 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Fast-food chain serving signature beef, chicken & fish sliders, plus extras such as onion rings.

    One review mentioned:

    Belly bombs at there finest. location was redone a couple of years ago and they have kept up with it. drive up staff was great. advised me about making some changes with the order to save me a couple bucks. took the left overs to work and ate them cold the next day, almost as good as when fresh kid-friendliness: little delicious burgers. steamed to absolute yumminess

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    Open 24 hours

    Style: 
    Fast food restaurant

    (631) 467-3147
  • Image of Umami Sushi & Bar

    Umami Sushi & Bar

    4.2

    Umami Sushi & Bar, 1957 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Upscale and traditional all-you-can-eat japanese restaurant offering a wide-ranging sushi menu served in a modern, elegant setting.
    healthy options. great bar drink and cocktail selection. desserts
    great for both solo and family dining.

    One review mentioned:

    This is one of my favorite places to eat on long island! the all-you-can-eat sushi is fantastic. the pricing is amazing – around $20 a person for all-you-can-eat during lunch and a bit higher for dinner. you order the sushi on a tablet so it is super convenient and fast. the all-you-can-eat includes all sorts of sushi, sashimi, rolls, appetizers, cooked options, and deserts. i highly recommend umami sushi!

    Closed on: 
    Monday

    Timing: 
    11:30 AM-10 PM

    Style: 
    Sushi restaurant

    (631) 676-5553
  • Image of Istanbul Cafe

    Istanbul Cafe

    4.5

    Istanbul Cafe, 2139 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Served every day since 2009.
    istanbul cafe is open on all holidays. we serve healthy halal meat platters as well as vegetarian platters for our customers.
    we have wide variety of turkish bakery from baklava , kadeyif, kunefe, tresleches(turkish version), cheese cake, birthday cakes, semolina cookies, chocolate poppy seed cookies, almond cookies, bread and much much more..
    always serve fresh ,eat fresh…

    One review mentioned:

    I highly recommend istanbul cafe to anyone craving authentic turkish cuisine served with excellence! we tried fried liver, lamb shish, and lamb adana kabobs and they were amazing. the variety of delicious desserts they offer is impressive, catering to every sweet tooth. absolutely delightful experience! food : 5/5

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11 AM-12:50 AM

    Style: 
    Turkish restaurant

    (631) 738-6704
  • Image of Buffalo Wild Wings

    Buffalo Wild Wings

    4.0

    Buffalo Wild Wings, 1986 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Award-winning buffalo, new york-style wings in your choice of 26 sauces and seasonings.

    One review mentioned:

    Service and wings were great. went for the islanders game and had a great time although they lost, but that s besides the point. i m a little bit of a wimp with spice but the honey barbecue wings are the best in the area.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11 AM-12 AM

    Style: 
    Chicken wings restaurant

    (631) 683-8190
  • Image of Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

    Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

    4.1

    Olive Garden Italian Restaurant, 257 Centereach Mall, Centereach, NY 11720

    All of your favorites are just a few clicks away! view our menu online and order to go now or come in for our famous never-ending first course of freshly baked breadsticks and your choice of homemade soup or garden fresh salad. enjoy abundant portions of classic entrees the whole family craves like the tour of italy, our irresistible chicken parmigiana, or everyone’s favorite fettuccine alfredo, made fresh from our kitchen to your table. gather together with the people you love over a meal worth sharing at olive garden. when you’re here, you’re family.

    One review mentioned:

    My wifes favorite restaurant…and yes shes italian. ya cant miss with pasta refills. our server was super nice. i can not for the life of me remember her name, but she said the record is 7 refills on the pasta.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11 AM-10 PM

    Style: 
    Italian restaurant

    (631) 585-4027
  • Image of New Golden Buffet

    New Golden Buffet

    4.0

    New Golden Buffet, 141 Centereach Mall, Centereach, NY 11720

    A vast array of american, chinese, & japanese dishes in a buffet format with a casual interior.

    One review mentioned:

    Service was amazing, seated right away. food was hot and fresh! always bringing out food. i highly recommend $22 for lunch

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    10 AM-10 PM

    Style: 
    Buffet restaurant

    (631) 588-5188
  • Image of El Rio Restaurant

    El Rio Restaurant

    4.0

    El Rio Restaurant, 2133 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    El rio restaurant provides authentic mexican cuisine for dine-in, take-out, delivery, and catering to the centereach, ny area.

    One review mentioned:

    Excellent resteraunt nice ambience good food and drinks. the owner was very nice and affable its worth a go

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11 AM-11 PM

    Style: 
    Mexican restaurant

    (631) 468-8901
  • Image of Cabo Fresh

    Cabo Fresh

    4.5

    Cabo Fresh, 1759 Middle Country Rd Unit M, Centereach, NY 11720

    Cabo fresh is a fast casual, california inspired mexican grill. we believe in real food that is fresh, flavorful, and fast. eating well should be easy, accessible, and affordable. we believe in cooking from scratch using whole, fresh ingredients every day. we believe in connecting our team, our suppliers, our customers, and our community for the good of all. we feature healthy all natural ingredients and prepare our recipes from scratch.

    One review mentioned:

    From start to finish cabo was incredible! they made it so easy to cater for my sons party. the food was incredible. the quality and the service. they came to set up band brought everything we needed. i couldn t have asked for anything better and will be having my sons birthday catered by cabo! can t wait ! thank you cabo!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    10:45 AM-10 PM

    Style: 
    Mexican restaurant

    (631) 580-2226
  • Image of ESPARTA DELI

    Esparta Deli

    5.0

    ESPARTA DELI, 2501 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Comida centroamericana

    One review mentioned:

    Very solid carne asada tacos. authentic food, great service & friendly owner. cantaloupe juice was great on a beautiful summer day. will be back to try more food soon. thanks juan

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    6 AM-10 PM

    Style: 
    Central American restaurant

    (631) 468-8512
  • Image of Plaza Margarita Restaurant

    Plaza Margarita Restaurant

    4.4

    Plaza Margarita Restaurant, 2055 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Mexican and spanish food

    One review mentioned:

    Very friendly and delicious. the margaritas are the best ive had on li. period. very attentive staff and extremely polite. made me feel like family at the first meeting. had a chance to go back and eat . the best mexican restaurant in suffolk county i am sure. nora is the sweetest proprietor ever! you are treated as family and the food and staff ate just wonderful. do yourselves a favor and join the addiction . my tastebuds are now spoiled.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    12-10 PM

    Style: 
    Mexican restaurant

    (631) 648-8614
  • Image of Arby's

    Arby’S

    4.0

    Arby's, 1759 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Arby’s is a leading global quick-service restaurant company operating and franchising over 3,400 restaurants worldwide. arby’s was the first nationally franchised, coast-to-coast sandwich chain and has been serving fresh, craveable meals since it opened its doors in 1964. the arby’s brand strives to inspire smiles through delicious experiences. we are on a never-ending quest for the perfect sandwich, starting with the classic roast beef and french dip to the deli-style market fresh line of sandwiches and salads.

    One review mentioned:

    Food and staff are great. they use these terrible paper straws there so be prepared to get your drink down, cant nurse it for 30+ minutes. also, the tvs in there are broken with a very strong blue tint one screens.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    10 AM-11 PM

    Style: 
    Fast food restaurant

    (631) 676-4957
  • Image of Pollo Rico Latin Bistro

    Pollo Rico Latin Bistro

    4.2

    Pollo Rico Latin Bistro, 2435 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Since its opening, pollo rico latin bistro has been consistently recognized as one of the best places in town to enjoy down home latin fare in a warm, friendly environment.

    One review mentioned:

    Colombian spot on mcr just so chillaxing perfect happy hour company. food is sooo tasty, it is definitely worth the price! got 3 beers on draft with a selection of cocktails that will keep you hydrated throughout the night. highly recommend their carne tacos. comes with pinto beans and rice!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11 AM-10 PM

    Style: 
    Colombian restaurant

    (631) 471-0585
  • Image of Moe's Southwest Grill

    Moe’S Southwest Grill

    4.0

    Moe's Southwest Grill, 243 Centereach Mall, Centereach, NY 11720

    ***our restaurants may be experiencing limited hours or may be closed. please call to confirm operating hours. thank you for your patience during this time*** welcome to southwestern food with a twist. welcome to burritos, nachos, quesadillas, tacos and burrito bowls made just for you. welcome to pico de gallo, seasonal salsas and good times made in house every day. enjoy free chips and salsa with every meal. welcome to moe’s centereach!

    One review mentioned:

    Great food & staff. each burrito hand rolled perfectly. food

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    10:30 AM-9 PM

    Style: 
    Mexican restaurant

    (631) 676-5540
  • Image of Dunkin'

    Dunkin’

    4.2

    Dunkin', 1327 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Dunkin’ is america’s favorite all-day, everyday stop for coffee, espresso, breakfast sandwiches and donuts. the world’s leading baked goods and coffee chain, dunkin’ serves more than 3 million customers each day. with 50+ varieties of donuts and dozens of premium beverages, there is always something to satisfy your craving.

    dunkin’ is proud to serve centereach, ny for all breakfast and snacking needs. stop by today to try a classic favorite or a new featured product!

    One review mentioned:

    Very good service 24 hour duncan for late nite coffee or ice cream!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    Open 24 hours

    Style: 
    Coffee shop

    (631) 736-5186
  • Image of Tex's Chicken & Burgers

    Tex’S Chicken & Burgers

    4.2

    Tex's Chicken & Burgers, 2332 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Tex’s chicken & burgers is new york fast food restaurants that serves up always fresh, halal and southern style and comfort food every day. come on into our restaurant and try our delicious fried chicken and burgers. tex’s chicken & burgers purchase the freshest ingredients directly from local farmers. our burgers and chicken are never frozen- your food is prepared to order on every visit. we maintain an devoted love for the art of cooking; it’s what sets tex’s chicken & burgers apart – we love what we do, and it’s reflected in the quality of our food, from our chicken to our burgers. you don’t have to travel to the south – just stop by our locations. visit new york best fried chicken fast food restaurant. fried chicken near me.

    One review mentioned:

    I was not expecting such great quality at this store. the staff were extremely courteous. the food quality was very good. and to top it off, it was a 100% halal fried chicken place! will definitely be visiting jere more often.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    8 AM-4 AM

    Style: 
    Fast food restaurant

    (631) 615-2894
  • Image of Burger King

    Burger King

    4.0

    Burger King, 1880 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    There’s a burger king(r) restaurant near you at 1880 middle country rd. visit us or call for more information. every day, more than 11 million guests visit over 13,000 burger king(r) restaurants near them in 97 countries around the world. and they do so because our fast food restaurants are known for serving high-quality, great-tasting and affordable food. the burger king(r) restaurant in centereach, ny serves burgers, breakfast, lunch and dinner prepared your way.

    One review mentioned:

    Quick service at this drive-thru. food is typical burger king. like every other burger king. its burger king.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    7 AM-12 AM

    Style: 
    Restaurant

    (631) 738-1462
  • Image of Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen

    Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen

    4.1

    Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen, 1770 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

    Visit your local popeyes at 1770 middle country rd to savor our unique new orleans-style menu, featuring our fried chicken, flavor-packed wings, handcrafted chicken tenders, and a variety of delicious sides. whether you’re craving a quick lunch, a hearty dinner, or a family meal, we have you covered. order ahead online or on the popeyes app for pickup at a location near you, or get your meal delivered straight to your door. catering is also available at select locations.

    One review mentioned:

    Im a drive through customer. if you love spicy food and wings go get the sweet and spicy wings. so good

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    10:30 AM-11 PM

    Style: 
    Chicken restaurant

    (631) 648-8736
juanitasdiner
Juanita MariaWriter

I believe food is more than just something to eat - it's an art form that brings people together.

Juanitasdiner.com

All Posts
Don't miss out! Share this with your friends.

You Might Also Like: