New York

17 Top-Rated Steakhouses in Huntington, New York 2024

Jump to Spot

  • Image of PG Steakhouse

    Pg Steakhouse

    4.1

    PG Steakhouse, 1745 E Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743

    Family-owned fixture offering aged steaks & chops, served with classic side dishes in snug digs.

    One review mentioned:

    The food is simply amazing, one of the best steaks i ve ever had. the atmosphere and staff is very different than other steakhouses i ve been to however it was the most charming aspect. our waitress was so attentive, and kind. the restaurant is older, it s nice and quiet, and we enjoyed this so much to actually be alone or without so many people. 10/10 would go back!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    5-10 PM

    Style: 
    Steak house

    (631) 499-1005
  • Image of Sur Argentinean Steakhouse

    Sur Argentinean Steakhouse

    4.6

    Sur Argentinean Steakhouse, 314 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743

    Relaxed destination for latin-style meats & seafood in a wood-paneled, white-tablecloth setting.

    One review mentioned:

    1st visit to this cute little argentinian steakhouse and was very impressed. to start the staff was all very friendly. decided to try the parrillada tango which was an amazing array of meats, from steak to chicken to sweetbreads to argentinian sausage, short ribs, beef kidney and morcilla. this came with a choice of 2 sides and we added saute mushrooms & onions. everything was done so well and just beyond flavorful. ended with cappuccino amaretto and chaja which was a cake with peaches, dulce de leche & meringue. this was light and tasty. we will definitely be returning.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    12-9 PM

    Style: 
    Steak house

    (631) 470-6300
  • Image of IMC Restaurant & Bar

    Imc Restaurant & Bar

    4.5

    IMC Restaurant & Bar, 279 Main St, Huntington, NY 11743

    Imperial meat company the most glamorous newcomer to huntington village’s sizzling restaurant row is imc restaurant & bar, imperial meat company, a chic bistro with spectacular decor that stakes its claim to culinary excellence by starting with top-of-the-line provisions. long island foodies are bound to admire the imperial meat company as the gold standard in gourmet food & meat. the imperial meat company (imc) is the perfect venue for your next birthday party, bridal or baby shower, or corporate dinner. in addition to in-house catering, off-premise and backyard bbq menus are available with package to fit almost any budget.

    One review mentioned:

    Delicious cocktails! loved their smoky mezcal margarita and my friend loves the toasted coconut martini! we also had potato croquets, and the mussels were fabulous and crispy bread in that sauce was everything. we also had the thai calamari which is tangy and sweet. fantastic menu overall but super impressed with how extensive their happy hour menu items and cocktails and martinis are! (menus attached) will come back here again for sure!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    4-10 PM

    Style: 
    Steak house

    (631) 824-6222
  • Image of Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar

    Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar

    4.4

    Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, 117 North New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743

    Polished option for steak & seafood entrees including sushi, plus cocktails & scenic water views.

    One review mentioned:

    What a beautiful birthday dinner i had. the service is exceptional. i do appreciate all the staff and their hard work. it truly was a beautiful place & experience. as this was one of the first times i got to experience something a little more, lets just say fancy! we will be back! i highly, recommend this restaurant to any others as well. enjoy. we sure did. ty prime & staff. vegetarian options: im not a vegetarian but i do see many things on the menu, that would be perfect for someone that is a vegetarian. dietary restrictions: if you have any dietary issues, just let the waiter know. and he will let the cook and professionals know. parking: there are plenty of spaces for many cars to park.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11:30 AM-10 PM

    Style: 
    American restaurant

    (631) 385-1515
  • Image of Catch 25 Seafood & Steaks

    Catch 25 Seafood & Steaks

    4.7

    Catch 25 Seafood & Steaks, 326 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743

    Seafood & steak restaurant

    One review mentioned:

    Came here for the first time this past saturday to celebrate valentine s day. considering how packed the restaurant was, the food came out quickly and was very good. i got the special which was sea bass and it was prepared perfectly. our waitress was very friendly but not very present. it took me a while to flag her down. also the tables were a little too close for comfort; a woman sitting next to us was able to point to my plate and nearly touch my food. overall a great experience but i think it would be more enjoyable with some more space in between tables.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    4-10 PM

    Style: 
    Restaurant

    (631) 683-4731
  • Image of Dix Hills Diner

    Dix Hills Diner

    4.4

    Dix Hills Diner, 1800 E Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743

    Welcome to dix hills diner in huntington, new york – a favorite among locals and the best diner on long island according to our customers! experience dining where quality meets comfort, offering delicious meals with good portions at great prices. from our famous fries and mediterranean platter to kid-approved chicken fingers, there’s something for everyone. praised for our clean environment and friendly staff, we guarantee an exceptional experience every visit. perfect for sunday afternoon meals or any day of the week (open daily 8:00-22:00), dix hills diner is more than just a classic diner; it’s a place where food, service, and atmosphere come together perfectly. join us today!

    One review mentioned:

    Food very good to excellent..service as well..dinner specials are very good and worth the $-fair priced

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    8 AM-10 PM

    Style: 
    Diner

    No Data
  • Image of Samurai Hibachi

    Samurai Hibachi

    4.3

    Samurai Hibachi, 46-A Gerard St, Huntington, NY 11743

    Samurai features the classic hibachi cooking tables with private party rooms. our skilled hibachi chefs freshly prepare your meal right before your eyes. we at samurai are committed to serve you with the utmost freshness and an entertaining japanese hibachi experience. you can choose from our marvelous sirloin steak, our most tender filet mignon, or our succulent shrimp and lobster. to further your choices, we also offer teriyaki, tempura, and a full menu of sushi dishes. for your little one, samurai is child-friendly. your kids will be mesmerized as our hibachi chefs flip eggs into the air and light up the volcano fire. for your private affairs, we have private party rooms to accommodate guests from 15 to 125.

    One review mentioned:

    Samurai is the best of the best when it comes to hibachi in the huntington area. my family and i have been regular customers since i can remember. michael and simon are always extremely kind, welcoming, and accommodating and the wait staff is very attentive. their hibachi, sushi, etc. remain my favorite despite local competition. highly recommended, always!

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    3:30-10 PM

    Style: 
    Japanese restaurant

    (631) 271-2588
  • Image of The Rust & Gold

    The Rust & Gold

    4.1

    The Rust & Gold, 70 Gerard St, Huntington, NY 11743

    Modern american grub & craft beer in garage-style digs outfitted with trophies & sports memorabilia.

    One review mentioned:

    If you are looking for a lively sports bar with a good beer, burger, and crowd, then you must be looking for the rust & gold located in the heart of huntington village on gerard street. the industrial-type decor gives off a more urban vibe while the food screams comfort all through their menu. the staff is friendly and attentive. the chef prepares each item so it tastes delicious and amazingly seasoned at decent pricing. the place has good seating, multiple tvs, and a big bar that draws a crowd.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    4 PM-2 AM

    Style: 
    Bar

    (631) 629-4431
  • Image of Red

    Red

    4.5

    Red, 417 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743

    Locally sourced new american cuisine & fine wines in a lively, red-accented space & outdoor garden.

    One review mentioned:

    Everything was delicious, and the service was excellent. the cod special and scallops appetizer were truly delightful. another aspect that makes the restaurant stand out is its non-alcoholic selection, offering a variety of cocktails and beers to satisfy those looking for a non-alcoholic beverage.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    12-9 PM

    Style: 
    American restaurant

    (631) 673-0304
  • Image of Cafe Buenos Aires

    Cafe Buenos Aires

    4.4

    Cafe Buenos Aires, 23 Wall St, Huntington, NY 11743

    Elegant argentinean spot starring steaks & tapas, with a lively bar & tango dancers on weekends.

    One review mentioned:

    Food really stands out here. the waitress said the paella is one of the best things on the menu. we thought it was so worth it. our waitress, isabel, was friendly and on point all evening. i gave atmosphere 4 stars as this has been a busy neighborhood staple for years, and it kinda shows. dont let that stop you tho, experience was so enjoyable.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    5-10 PM

    Style: 
    Argentinian restaurant

    (631) 603-3600
  • Image of The Farm Italy Restaurant & Bar

    The Farm Italy Restaurant & Bar

    4.4

    The Farm Italy Restaurant & Bar, 12 Gerard St, Huntington, NY 11743

    The farm italy brings the simplicity, artistry and seasonal freshness of local italian dining to huntington, ny. from the creators of the shed restaurants, besito mexican restaurants & ballo italian… welcome to the farm italy. sign-up for the latest news on our website!

    the farm italy restaurant + bar, coming soon to 12 gerard st. huntington, ny

    One review mentioned:

    The culinary experience here is distinguished by high-quality, authentic, and fresh ingredients, meticulously crafted into thoughtful and delectable italian dishes. although the service is satisfactory, it doesnt quite rise to the level of the exceptional food and ambiance, hinting at potential for improvement. overall, its a wonderful place for genuine italian cuisine, but with a boost in service quality, it could reach new heights of excellence.

    Closed on: 
    Monday

    Timing: 
    12-10 PM

    Style: 
    Restaurant

    (631) 824-6000
  • Image of Jonathan's Ristorante

    Jonathan’S Ristorante

    4.6

    Jonathan's Ristorante, 15 Wall St, Huntington, NY 11743

    Refined italian cuisine pairs with a renowned wine list in a warm, intimate space with patio tables.

    One review mentioned:

    Service was exceptional!! highly recommend the branzino the linguine. marlin was a wonderful waiter.. we will be back again!

    Closed on: 
    Monday

    Timing: 
    5-10 PM

    Style: 
    Italian restaurant

    (631) 549-0055
  • Image of OHK Bar & Restaurant

    Ohk Bar & Restaurant

    4.5

    OHK Bar & Restaurant, 135 W Gate Dr, Huntington, NY 11743

    Wine and dine in authentic european ambiance in america’s grandest castle. ohk bar & restaurant is nestled inside historic oheka castle on the gold coast of long island between new york city and the hamptons.

    One review mentioned:

    This is the first time i have been to oheka castle. we went for an investor meetup and had a couple of drinks and some food. the menu is interesting and had some nice upscale choices. the service was good, and the grounds and much of the building are very pretty. the outside courtyard atmosphere is very nice. the food was tasty, and the presentation was pretty good this place is quite expensive though… the charlie chaplin room is very cool vegetarian options: there are many vegetarian options on the menu parking: valet parking

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    12-10 PM

    Style: 
    American restaurant

    (631) 659-1400
  • Image of The Shed Restaurant - Huntington NY

    The Shed Restaurant – Huntington Ny

    4.6

    The Shed Restaurant - Huntington NY, 54 New St, Huntington, NY 11743

    The best brunch (all day), lunch & dinner in huntington village ny & on long island. everything is made from scratch.
    a bright take on american comfort food featuring a robust list of specialty breakfast menu items throughout the day alongside lunch & dinner items. the best ingredients, scratch kitchen and local sourcing wherever possible.

    One review mentioned:

    Update: also tried the biscuit benedict. the biscuit was nice, fluffy & buttery. the bacon was cooked perfectly. and the runny egg added creaminess to the plate. this place has an amazing atmosphere with bright natural light coming in. the food taste fresh. the shegg sandwich had tomatoe, bacon, cheese, egg, onion jam and arugula. sounds simple but bursting with flavor. the tomatoes tasted so fresh and the onion jam gave it a unique taste. the home fries were perfectly cooked with some crisp ends. the portions are pretty big too. the staff is very friendly and make you feel welcomed. parking: the location itself does not have parking but there is a parking lot across, also street parking

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    11 AM-9 PM

    Style: 
    American restaurant

    (631) 385-7433
  • Image of La Parma II Italian Restaurant

    La Parma Ii Italian Restaurant

    4.6

    La Parma II Italian Restaurant, 452 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743

    We are happily open for dining both in our outdoor tented oasis and inside in our formal dining area. please call for reservations today!

    One review mentioned:

    Best italian restaurant in new york. they hit on the classic dishes with perfect precision. la parma also has some creative unique dishes that never disappoint. the staff is super welcoming and it feels like dining with family. the overall experience will absolutely leave you full and happy that you decided to visit this long island treasure.

    Closed on: 
    Monday

    Timing: 
    12-9 PM

    Style: 
    Italian restaurant

    (631) 367-6360
  • Image of Piccolo

    Piccolo

    4.6

    Piccolo, 215 Wall St, Huntington, NY 11743

    Upscale restaurant serving classic & contemporary italian dishes, plus an extensive wine list.

    One review mentioned:

    Birthday dinner. jason gave us the best table in the house on short notice and the food and service was perfect. salmon for one dish, pork tomey special for second dish. just outstanding. check out the pics. great food and drinks. from the bar and martinis to the house specials, great flavor, good portions and happy smiling staff eager to help.

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    4-10 PM

    Style: 
    Italian restaurant

    (631) 424-5592
  • Image of Kashi

    Kashi

    4.6

    Kashi, 12 Elm St, Huntington, NY 11743

    Creative takes on sushi & japanese fare plus sake list amid neon-blue lighting & buzzing bar scene.

    One review mentioned:

    Best sushi ive had in a very long time. everything taste amazing, sushi tasted like it was caught right before it came to your table. service was great,the rolls come in 8 pcs and are huge…..come hungry and leave satisfied to the max

    Closed on: 
    Open All Days

    Timing: 
    12-3 PM, 4:30-10 PM

    Style: 
    Japanese restaurant

    (631) 923-1960
juanitasdiner
Juanita MariaWriter

I believe food is more than just something to eat - it's an art form that brings people together.

Juanitasdiner.com

All Posts
Don't miss out! Share this with your friends.

Restaurant Styles

You Might Also Like: